The Best Potato Masher for Non-Stick Pans [Scratch-Free Food Prep]

As an Amazon Associate We earn from qualifying purchases.

From helping you create the smoothest mashed potatoes and the healthiest baby food, potato mashers are a versatile utensil every kitchen should have.

However, although convenient for mashing right into cookware and easing food prep, many users worry about it scratching their bottom, especially the non-stick ones.

If you also worry about this, it’s pivotal to choose the right type of masher for a non-stick surface. It won’t damage it and you can mash worry-free.

Without a doubt, non-stick pots and pans have a long list of advantages and a common choice today. However, they need proper care to last and stay free of scratches!

They dislike metal utensils and prefer something softer like silicone or silicone-coated materials.

Mashed potatoes with potato masher for non-stick pan on wooden table

If you love using a potato masher, but you’re not sure how it pairs with your non-stick pans, stick with us! We’ll present the 10 best potato mashers for non-stick pans.

Top Pick

Zulay’s Potato Masher with Silicone Coated Head is our best pick because of its sturdy construction, quality materials, and longevity.

It will help you create yummy meals easily while protecting your non-stick cookware and bakeware.

Budget Pick

OXO’s Good Grips’ Nylon Potato Masher offers great value for the money and it will ensure easy food prep while keeping your pots and pans safe.

It’s also dishwasher-safe and boasts a comfy handle, for effortless maneuvers.

Why Do I Need A Special Kind Of Potato Masher For My Non-Stick Pans?

Cookware or bakeware with non-stick coating is amazing for healthier cooking due to the need for less oil.

However, if you fail to care for it the right way, including using the wrong utensils, it may peel or chip off and impede its cleaning and longevity.

When it comes to prepping foods directly into the non-stick pot or pan, for example, mashed potatoes, it’s best to use a rubber or silicone masher.

This minimizes the risk of damage and prolongs the longevity of your precious cookware.

Avoid the metal stuff with your non-stick pans, especially whiskers. They’re sharp and tough and can damage the coating!

Benefits Of Potato Mashers For Non-Stick Cookware?

To Keep Non-Stick Cookware Safe

When a potato masher is described as safe for non-stick cookware, it means it’s been coated with materials like nylon or silicone that are gentle to the coating.

That is, it cannot make scratches or damage it.

By using these types of utensils with non-stick pots and pans, you help prolong their lifespan and maximize their performance.

Don’t Spend a Lot Of Money

One of the best things about manual mashers is that they’re budget-friendly, yet have a lot of advantages to offer.

At around 10 bucks, you can have a quality potato masher that is versatile and long-lasting.

From mashing potatoes to prepping fruits for baby food, it’s really an indispensable utensil!

To Use It with Hot Foods

All of the potato mashers we presented are perfectly suitable for usage with hot foods. Unfortunately, this isn’t the case with all potato mashers.

The poor quality ones tend to warp or get burned from high temperatures.

But not the ones we found! They’ve been specially designed to withstand high heat.

To Make a Long-Lasting Investment

Don’t let their compact look fool you: these potato mashers are very sturdy and long-lasting. They aren’t costly, yet last for a long period.

However, it’s essential to care for them the right way and to use them as advised by the manufacturer.

To Have a Versatile Kitchen Utensil

Besides helping you prep magical mashed potatoes directly into the pot, you can also use this utensil to prep a long list of other foods, including guacamole, baby food, sauces, marinades, and so much more.

Which Factors to Consider Before Buying?

Material of the Masher

When looking to buy the best potato masher for non-stick pans, it’s essential to choose one that’s coated with silicone or nylon because these materials won’t scratch the cookware’s surface.

And, their base must be constructed with stainless steel because this is a sturdy, long-lasting, and non-rusting material.

Head of the Masher

The bottom part of manual mashers, also known as the head, can be designed in various ways, but the two most common ones are round with several tiny holes and the ones with a wire-like design.

The former is praised for giving a smoother texture than the latter, although they also do a terrific job!

And, the bigger perforations will demand less force from you than the larger ones; but, they’ll produce a coarser texture.

Size of the Masher

Although a larger potato masher head will help you tackle the potatoes faster, it may not be desirable for smaller batches and there’s also the need for more free storage space.

A medium-size handle and head would be ideal. Also, we appreciate the models with foldable heads, like the one by Joseph Joseph we presented!

It’s innovative, effective, and a real space-saver.

Handle of the Masher

In addition to the head, the potato masher’s handle is also important. And, the longer and the sturdier, the better.

It’s pivotal to be ergonomically designed and if possible, padded with extra materials that will maximize comfort and balance.

Moreover, when possible, choose one-piece potato mashers; this decreases the risk of the device breaking.

We also appreciate the ones with loopholes on the top that enable easy storage on kitchen racks, which is great for low space kitchens!

Maintenance of the Masher

Nowadays, with so little free time to ourselves, it matters if our kitchen utensils are easy to maintain or not.

If you’re the type who prefers the dishwasher, you’re good to go with any of our models; all of them are suitable for the sink and dishwasher.

And, thanks to their non-sticky heads, removing food residues is effortless.

How to Care For My Potato Masher for Non-Stick Pans?

Here at Knife Verge, we constantly remind our readers that if they care for their knives and other kitchen utensils, they will last.

And, the same advice applies to potato mashers.

The ones designed to be used with non-stick pans are easy to clean, but this needs to be done in the right way. All of the models we presented are dishwasher-safe or can be washed in the sink.

Moreover, they’re not too demanding in terms of additional care; they just need to be washed after every use.

And, if you notice some food stuck in the holes, remove it timely by scrubbing it off to prevent bacteria from breeding. For stubborn food remains, soaking in warm water will help you clean it easier.

If you choose a model with a wave-like head, be careful with the storage to prevent it from being bent by heavier appliances and tools.

If you put it in the drawer, store it on the top, rather than the bottom.

Our Top Picks

10 Best Potato Mashers for Non-Stick Pans Review

1. Zulay Silicone-Coated Potato Masher

Highlighted Features

  • Sturdy design
  • Quality materials
  • Easy to use
  • Long-lasting
  • Doesn’t scratch cookware

Product Information

Package Dimensions12.71 x 6.02 x 3.31 inches
Item Weight6.3 ounces
MaterialSilicone and Stainless Steel
ColorRuby Red
ManufacturerZulay Kitchen

Inexpensive and available in three colors, this premium stainless steel potato masher coated with silicone is ideal for non-stick cookware.

It will meet all your expectations for the yummiest, lump-free mashed potatoes and other delightful foods.

The durable silicone coating lasts and ensures you get fluffy mashed potatoes every time while still keeping your cookware free of scratches.

The design is long-lasting and durable. The thick head under the coating is made with premium stainless steel.

The handle offers awesome grip, comfort, and performance. It’s strong and rounded, constructed of stainless steel, and won’t bend or rust.

Since food doesn’t stick to its silicone coating, you can easily keep it clean; do it in the dishwasher or by hand, both are just fine.

2. Farberware Nylon Potato Masher for Non-Stick Pans

Highlighted Features

  • Optimized blade design
  • Easy to use & clean
  • Safe for non-stick cookware & heat-resistant
  • Comfy handle
  • Lifetime warranty (limited)

Product Information

Package Dimensions10.71 x 2.48 x 2.17 inches
Item Weight5 ounces
MaterialNylon
ColorBlack
ManufacturerFarberware

This is an amazing multi-purpose mixer and masher for the yummiest lump-free mashed potatoes.

It features a 5-blade design and helps you mash potatoes, but many other veggies and fruits to perfection too.

Being coated with a BPA-free nylon head, it’s heat-resistant to temperatures up to 450 degrees F.

It’s safe for usage on any type of non-stick cookware and bakeware. You’ll no longer have to whisk in a different pot, but directly in the one, you’ll be cooking in.

Thanks to the angled design of the blades, it ensures the content on the sides is also mashed.

Moreover, we love its comfy and rounded handle, optimizing the comfort while working.

The cleaning is the easiest part; you can do it in the sink or the dishwasher.

3. OXO Good Grips’s Nylon Potato Masher

Highlighted Features

  • Sturdy
  • Heat-resistant
  • Soft & comfy handle
  • Great for non-stick cookware
  • Dishwasher-safe

Product Information

Package Dimensions11 x 4 x 3.38 inches
Item Weight5 ounces
MaterialNylon
ColorBlack
ManufacturerOXO

If you’re looking for a potato masher you can use with non-stick cookware, this one will meet all of your needs.

In addition to being made from nylon and keeping your non-stick pots and pans safe, you can also use them with hot foods.

In fact, it can resist heat up to 400 degrees F. The ergonomic handle is lovely-it’s soft, and non-slippery, making sure you’re always comfy while using the masher.

Whether you’ll wash it in the sink or the dishwasher, this masher is easy to clean and long-lasting. Customers who purchased it gave the most kudos for being sturdy, easy to use, and easy to hold.

4. Tovolo Silicone Coated Potato Masher for Non-Stick Pans

Highlighted Features

  • Excellent value for money
  • Easy to use & clean
  • Sturdy
  • Durable

Product Information

Package Dimensions5.38 x 5.25 x 0.94 inches
Item Weight1.6 ounces
MaterialSilicone, Stainless Steel
ColorCharcoal
ManufacturerSpectrum Diversified Designs

If you want to mash without scratching your non-stick cookware, you need this masher.

Its head is coated with strong BPA-free silicone and ideal for all those sensitive non-stick pots and pans.

The head features a curved wire design that will help you mash a long list of veggies and fruits to perfection.

Let’s not forget the sturdy, rounded handle from stainless steel. It doesn’t just add to the style, but to the utensil’s functionality too.

It’s ergonomic and comfy and helps you feel in control. What’s more, feel free to use it with hot foods; it can withstand temperatures up to 600 degrees F.

When you’re done using it, clean it hassle-free in the sink or the dishwasher; it’s suitable for both!

5. Cooking Light Potato Masher for Non-Stick Cookware

Highlighted Features

  • Made from sturdy material
  • Comfy handle
  • BPA-free
  • Easy to use & clean
  • Safe for non-stick cookware

Product Information

Package Dimensions13.1 x 3.2 x 3 inches
Item Weight3.98 ounces
MaterialNylon
ColorBlack
ManufacturerEpoca International

Made from heavy and durable nylon, this potato masher is ideal for mashing potatoes and other fruits and veggies effortlessly.  

And, you can do it right into your non-stick pan or pot because it won’t scratch or damage them.

It allows you to mash comfortably and easily, while in complete control. This is achieved with the non-slip, ergonomic handle.

The masher is versatile and easy to clean; you can do it in the sink or the dishwasher. Being heat-resistant, this nylon potato masher is excellent for usage with hot foods.

Customers who purchased it praised it the most for being ergonomic, offering good value for the money, and being easy to clean.

6. Jell Cell Silicone-Coated Potato Masher

Highlighted Features

  • Safe for non-stick cookware
  • Sturdy construction
  • Versatile
  • Heat-resistant
  • Easy to clean

Product Information

Package Dimensions9.7 x 5.4 x 1.5 inches
Item Weight6.4 ounces
MaterialSilicone+stainless steel
ColorRed
ManufacturerJell-Cell

This sturdy potato masher is made of strong stainless steel and its wire head has been coated with food-safe silicone to keep your non-stick cookware safe.

The strong steel handle is comfy and allows you to do the mashing perfectly. The head won’t rust or get damaged.

Whether potatoes or avocados, it has your back-feel free to do the mashing right into the pots and pans. Moreover, since it can withstand temperatures of up to 600 degrees F, you can freely use it with hot foods.

Customers who purchased this masher loved it the most for being easy to clean, its sturdiness, and easy use.

7. Calphalon Nylon Potato Masher

Highlighted Features

  • Suitable for non-stick cookware
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Versatile
  • Made of sturdy nylon
  • BPA-free

Product Information

Package Dimensions10.31 x 4.1 x 2.95 inches
Item Weight3.42 ounces
MaterialNylon
ColorBlack
ManufacturerCalphalon

Inexpensive and suitable for mashing right into your non-stick pots, this masher is a great investment.

It’s constructed using BPA-free sturdy nylon and features a comfy handle and a wide head for effortless mashing.

You can use it for a lot more than potatoes, including various fruits and veggies, and prep yummy meals. Feel free to use it with hot foods and don’t fear it will melt or warp; it’s able to resist up to 400 degrees F!

When you’re done using it, the cleaning is straightforward; put it in the dishwasher or rinse it in the sink, both are perfect!

Let’s not forget that the product comes with a lifetime warranty, which is awesome!

8. Tenta Kitchen Nylon Potato Masher for Non-Stick Cookware

Highlighted Features

  • Versatile
  • Made of strong materials
  • Easy to store, use, and clean
  • Great for non-stick cookware

Product Information

Package Dimensions10.24 x 3.35 x 3.35 inches
Item Weight3.1 ounces
MaterialNylon
ManufacturerTENTA7

This potato masher boasts an 18/8 stainless steel construction and a food-grade nylon coating.

Long-lasting and tough, its ergonomic design ensures you mash potatoes and other fruits and veggies effortlessly.

The handle is rounded and comfy, providing great balance. It also features a loop on the top, easing storage.

Feel free to prep with it directly into your non-stick cookware since it won’t damage or scratch them.

And, no need to fear hot foods damaging it-it can withstand heat up to 400 degrees F. Once you’re done using it, put it in the dishwasher or rinse it in the sink.

Customers who bought it considered it the best for its easy cleaning, sturdiness, and easy use.

9. Joseph Joseph Folding Potato Masher

Highlighted Features

  • Safe for non-stick cookware
  • User-friendly design
  • Versatile
  • Comfy handle
  • Durable materials

Product Information

Package Dimensions1.57 x 3.94 x 11.89 inches
Item Weight2.56 ounces
MaterialPlastic, Stainless steel
ColorGray/Green
ManufacturerJOSEPH JOSEPH

This amazing potato masher is suitable for non-stick cookware and comes with an interesting and useful design.

Its head boasts sturdy nylon while the handle is stainless steel and also padded for extra comfort.

The handle is ergonomically designed and helps you feel in control while mashing, but also without any pressure in the hands.

Namely, thanks to the foldable head part, it can easily fit into curved bowls or be stored in smaller areas. When you’re done using it, you can wash it in the dishwasher or the sink.

Its stainless steel shaft comes with a locking collar to keep it in place when folded.

10. Amazon Basics’ Nylon Potato Masher

Highlighted Features

  • Sturdy construction
  • Safe for non-stick cookware
  • Easy to use & clean
  • Versatile
  • Dishwasher-safe

Product Information

Package Dimensions11.4 x 3.6 x 3.2 inches
Item Weight3.84 ounces
MaterialNylon
ManufacturerAmazon Basics

Suitable for making yummy mashed potatoes, guacamole, or baby food, this masher is constructed from durable nylon.

It boasts a wide flat bottom head with laser-cut holes, speeding up the mashing. And, it’s safe to use directly into non-stick cookware. It won’t scratch or damage it.

The non-slip and soft-grip handle made from the same material is sturdy and offers ideal control and balance. What’s more, cleaning is the easiest thing ever; it’s suitable for the dishwasher and sink.

And, once it’s dry, feel free to hang it on your kitchen rack using the hole on the top of the handle or in the drawer!

Final Thoughts

Without a doubt, non-stick cookware and bakeware are growing in popularity and one of its best benefits is healthier food prep without too much oil, amongst others.

However, for these pots and pans to last, we need to use them and care for them properly. The emphasis is on using the right utensils when mixing or mashing inside them.

Since metal can damage it and cause scratches and decrease longevity, it’s pivotal to avoid them.

Instead, opt for nylon or silicone coated utensils, like the best potato masher for non-stick pans. With this masher, you can freely mash directly into the pots, without worries.

Our best pick is amazing-it’s versatile, easy to use, and safe for non-stick pots and pans.

Our budget pick will keep your budget safe, but ensure a satisfying experience while mashing mouth-watering potatoes to perfection!

Leave a Comment